Tandas Are Legal: Understanding the Legality of Community Savings Circles
Tandas, also known as cundinas, susus, juntas or rotating savings and credit associations (ROSCAs), are a popular form of community-based financial cooperation in many cultures.
These informal savings clubs have been a cornerstone of financial support for communities around the world for generations. But are they legal? Yes!
Let's dive into the legality of tandas and how they function as a form of mutual aid and community support.
Dinero Con Confianza
💵
Dinero Con Confianza 💵
The Legal Status of Tandas
In most cases, tandas are legal. They operate as a form of mutual aid and community support, falling outside the traditional banking system.
Tandas are essentially a type of micro-financing that doesn't involve formal financial institutions. Here's why they're generally considered legal:
1. Mutual Agreement: Participants voluntarily enter into an agreement with each other, not with a financial institution.
2. No Interest: Traditional tandas don't charge interest, which helps them avoid being classified as lending institutions.
3. Community-Based: They're rooted in trust and social ties within a community, not commercial relationships.
4. Non-Profit Nature: Tandas are not operated for profit, but for mutual benefit.
Tandas operate as a form of mutual aid and community support, falling outside the traditional banking system.
Legal Limits on Tanda Amounts
While tandas are legal, it's important to note that there can be legal implications based on the amount of money involved.
In the United States, for example, there isn't a specific law that sets a maximum amount for tandas. However, large amounts of money changing hands can trigger reporting requirements or raise red flags with financial regulators.
The key thresholds to be aware of are:
1. $10,000 Cash Transaction Reporting: Banks and financial institutions are required to report cash transactions over $10,000 to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). While tandas typically operate outside of banks, if participants are depositing or withdrawing large sums related to a tanda, it could potentially trigger these reports.
2. $15,000 Gift Tax Reporting: If any single contribution to a tanda participant exceeds $15,000 in a year, it could potentially be viewed as a gift for tax purposes, requiring the filing of a gift tax return.
3. Structure of the Tanda: Larger tandas with many participants or high contribution amounts might attract more scrutiny and could potentially be viewed as an informal banking operation.
It's advisable to keep tanda amounts below these thresholds and within reasonable limits for personal finance management.
If a tanda grows very large, it might be wise to consult with a financial advisor or legal professional to ensure compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.
Comunidad-Inspired, Future-Focused
☀️
Comunidad-Inspired, Future-Focused ☀️
Tandas as Mutual Aid and Community Support
Tandas exemplify the spirit of mutual aid and community support. They allow individuals to:
Pool resources to help each other achieve financial goals
Build a safety net for emergencies
Foster financial discipline and savings habits
Strengthen community bonds and trust
When Tandas Can Become Problematic & How ROSCA Is Here To Help
While tandas are generally legal, there are situations where they can cross into questionable legal territory:
1. Non-Payment: If a participant fails to make their contributions, it can be difficult to enforce repayment through legal means, as these agreements are often informal.
2. Interest Charges: If the organizer or any participant charges interest, it could be seen as operating an unlicensed financial service, which is typically illegal.
3. Large-Scale Operations: If tandas grow too large or begin to operate like a business, they might attract regulatory scrutiny.
R.O.S.C.A. Money Circle enhances the transparency and accountability of tandas through digital record-keeping and automated reminders, reducing the risk of missed payments and misunderstandings.
The app formalizes agreements between participants and provides educational resources, helping to keep tandas within legal boundaries and prevent potential disputes.
By managing group sizes and reinforcing the traditional interest-free structure, R.O.S.C.A. helps tandas maintain their community-based nature while minimizing the risk of attracting regulatory scrutiny.
The Role of R.O.S.C.A. Money Circle
R.O.S.C.A. Money Circle plays a crucial role in preserving and modernizing the tradition of tandas. While our platform doesn’t move money within the app, they provides valuable services:
Organizing and tracking tanda participation
Sending reminders for payments
Providing a clear record of transactions
By offering these tools, R.O.S.C.A. Money Circle and similar apps help keep the tradition of tandas alive while adding a layer of organization and accountability. This can help prevent misunderstandings and reduce the risk of non-payment issues.
